The right grill comes down to two questions: how you like to cook, and where the grill will live. Gas is the easiest everyday grill, charcoal and kamado grills give the most smoke and sear, pellet grills make low and slow smoking push-button simple, and a griddle handles everything that would fall through the grates. Then decide whether it is built into an outdoor kitchen, standing on the patio, or going tailgating. Here is how each type compares, and our picks for each.

Types of Grills Compared
| Type | Fuel | Best for | Keep in mind |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gas grill | Natural gas or propane | Weeknight grilling, outdoor kitchens | Less smoke flavor than charcoal or wood |
| Charcoal grill | Charcoal | Smoky flavor and high-heat searing | Longer to light and to clean up |
| Kamado grill | Charcoal | Smoking, roasting and baking | Heavy ceramic, best left in one spot |
| Pellet grill | Wood pellets, with electricity | Low and slow smoking with set-and-forget control | Needs power to run |
| Griddle (flat top) | Natural gas or propane | Breakfast, smash burgers, stir-fry | Not a substitute for grill marks |
| Electric grill | 240V electricity | Places that do not allow gas or charcoal | Needs a dedicated circuit |
| Fire pit grill | Wood or charcoal | Cooking over a live fire, then sitting around it | Cooking takes some practice |
| Hybrid multi-fuel | Gas plus wood or charcoal | One grill that does both | Larger and more involved to install |
Gas vs Charcoal Grill
Gas wins on convenience, charcoal wins on flavor. A gas grill lights with a knob, holds a steady temperature, and is ready in minutes, which is why it is the grill most people use on a Tuesday night. Charcoal takes longer to light and leaves ash to clean out, but it gives food a smokier taste and can run very hot for searing.
You do not have to choose. A hybrid grill such as the American Made Grills Muscle 36 runs on gas and also takes wood or charcoal in trays under the grates, and the Fire Magic Aurora A830i puts a gas grill and a charcoal grill side by side in one built-in unit.

Natural Gas vs Propane Grill
Natural gas is cheaper to run, propane goes anywhere. A natural gas grill connects to your home's gas line, so it never runs out mid-cookout, and natural gas usually costs less than propane for the same heat. It needs a gas line run to the grill by a licensed gas fitter. Propane runs off a tank, so the grill can sit anywhere on the patio, but you have to keep a spare tank on hand.

Order the right fuel. Most built-in gas grills are sold as either natural gas or propane, and you choose when you order. Converting later usually needs a conversion kit from the maker, so decide before you buy.
Built-In, Freestanding, Post-Mount or Portable
- Built-in: the grill head drops into an outdoor kitchen island. It is the cleanest look and gives you countertop on both sides. Plan the island around the grill's cutout dimensions, which are in each product's manual.
- Freestanding: the grill sits on a cart you can roll around the patio. The Broilmaster P3X mounts on a cart or a post, so you can start on a cart and make it permanent later.
- Post-mount: the grill head sits on a single post set in the ground or on a patio base. The PGS A40 mounts on a post, a pedestal or a portable base.
- Portable: small enough to take tailgating, camping or to the beach. See our picks for the road below.

What to Look For in a Grill
- Cooking area. Compare the primary cooking area in square inches, not just the width. Two 36-inch grills can differ a lot in how much food they hold.
- Burners and heat zones. More burners with separate controls let you cook hot on one side and gentle on the other.
- Construction. 304 stainless steel holds up best outdoors. Cast aluminum grill heads, like Broilmaster and PGS, are light and resist rust.
- Sear burner, rotisserie and lights. An infrared sear burner gives steakhouse-style crust, a rotisserie handles whole chickens and roasts, and interior lights help after dark. The American Made Grills Estate 36 includes a rotisserie kit, an infrared sear burner, a smoker tray and a griddle plate.
- Ignition. Battery-free ignition, like the FlameThrower system on American Outdoor Grill models, lights without power. Hot surface ignition, like Fire Magic's, needs a power connection.
- Safety features. Thermocouple safety valves shut off the gas if the flame goes out, and some grills, like the PGS Legacy line, add a timer that shuts the gas off automatically.

Our Picks by Need
Best for a high-end outdoor kitchen: Fire Magic Aurora A790i. A 38-inch built-in gas grill with 792 sq. in. of cooking space, Diamond Sear cooking grids, interior halogen lights and backlit knobs.

Best value built-in gas grill: American Outdoor Grill T-Series 36. A 300 series stainless steel built-in with Diamond Sear grids and FlameThrower ignition that lights without batteries or electricity. For a modern black finish, look at the Wildfire Ranch PRO 36, built from 304 stainless steel with 58,000 BTU of cast stainless burners.
Best for gas and charcoal in one: American Made Grills Muscle 36. Five 22,000 BTU gas burners, plus trays that hold wood or charcoal right under the grates.
Best griddle: Le Griddle Pro Series 75. A 30-inch built-in flat top with a triple-layer stainless steel plate, two independently controlled zones and thermocouple safety valves. For a black stainless outdoor kitchen, the Wildfire Ranch PRO 30-Inch Griddle matches the Wildfire grills.
Best kamado grill: Primo Oval XL 400. A ceramic charcoal grill whose thick ceramic holds heat for smoking, roasting or baking, with a patented oval shape that maximizes the cooking area and reversible grates: one side for searing, the other for more delicate food.
Best pellet grill: Green Mountain Grills Ledge Prime 2.0. A wood pellet grill with Wi-Fi control from your phone, dual meat probes and a 150°F to 550°F range. For an outdoor kitchen, the Top Fires Diamond Series Pellet Grill builds into the island and holds 22 lb of pellets.

Best for cooking over a live fire: Arteflame Classic 40. A corten steel fire pit with a carbon steel cooktop ring that cooks hottest at the center and gentler at the edge. Lift off the cooktop and it is a fire pit for the rest of the evening. Arteflame makes it in the USA. Browse all our fire pit grills.

Best electric grill: PGS Legacy E27T. A 240V built-in electric grill for condos and spaces where gas or charcoal is not allowed, with a one-hour timer. It needs a dedicated 240V circuit, so plan on an electrician.
Best for the road: Hitchfire F-20 and Top Fires Overlander. The Hitchfire mounts to your vehicle's hitch, swings aside so you can still open the trunk, and lifts off for tabletop grilling. The Overlander is a portable propane grill in marine-grade stainless steel with a cast iron cooking surface. For pellet smoking at the campsite, the Green Mountain Grills Trek Prime 2.0 runs on 12V power.

Grill Safety Basics
- Follow the clearances in the manual. Every grill lists how far it must sit from walls, railings and overhangs, and built-in grills list the island materials they need.
- Use an insulated jacket in a combustible island. Many built-in gas grills require one if the island is framed in wood. Check the manual before you build.
- Keep the grease tray clean. Most flare-ups and grease fires start there.
- Check gas connections. Brush soapy water on the connections at the start of the season; bubbles mean a leak.
- Never grill indoors or in an enclosed space. That includes garages and covered porches with no airflow.
Need Help Choosing?
Tell us how you like to cook and send a sketch of your patio or outdoor kitchen, and we will recommend a grill that fits. Email support@patiofever.com, or use our free design service. Browse all our grills.
Pin this article:
